i need reply of these statements one of the sufi said that if these muhaddiseen are not biddaties then we are also biddaties

***********
EDITED BY ADMIN: Please see "Following up on the doubts of the Innovators"

viewtopic.php?f=17&t=3619

as salaamu alaikum,

akhee, i don't know if you need a rebuttal, but just pay attention to the evidences that are being presented, and follow the truth according to the evidence, whether it is with you or with the one whom you wish to give a rebuttal to. it is obvious that there is at least some ikhtilaaf on the issue, so just pay attention, and ask allaah for understanding.