Salam aleykum

Here are words of shaykh Salih Luhaydan telling that Jarh and Ta'deel is finish, and does not exist today.

http://alathary.net/vb2/attachment.php? ... entid=3780

And by this followers of Falih tried to answer shaykh Rabee.

Of course, Sp and their secret agenda of showing words of scholars only that suit their secret programm and their hizb's views.

Maybe Sp do not want to see that shaykh Rabee can make ijtihad on some issues and be wrong, so his jarh on some people can be debattable.

Allah knows best their secret intention and their game of Jarh and Tadeel.

And some of their blind followers even called them spokseman of scholars...let's say of some scholars....those who agree with views of shaykh Rabee....

Salam aleykum

here is what followers of Falih brought, a tape of shaykh Rajihi saying that Jarh and Ta'deel is not found in our times, it is finished and compiled in books for Mouhaditheen.

http://www.alathary.net/vb2/attachment. ... entid=3335

And of course, Sp and their hizb will never show this kind of information opposing views of shaykh Rabee.

Salam aleykum

here is a tape brought by Falih's gang from shaykh Fawzan where he said he does not know nowdays any Imam of Jarh and Ta'deel and that is only knowledge of Isnad.

What will Sp do ?

Hide ikhtilaf of scholars on Jarh and Ta'deel or play their dangerous jarh and Ta'deel ?

Salam aleykum

Here is an audio from Al Ghudayan on same topic

He is asked wether today there are Imam of Jarh and Tadeel and he answered : Jarh and Tadeel is in books

And in second question the shaykh mentionned that Jarh and Ta'deel is in book for Asaneed.

Then being asked if shaykh Rabee was flagbearer of Jarh and Ta'deel, the saykh said no, and said it is for nobody

http://www.alathary.net/vb2/attachment. ... entid=3917

May Allah guide us all

salam

i recall few years ago when shaykh suhaib hasan had said that the era of jarh and ta'deel has finished, all the sp brothers were jumping on him like vultures. alhamdulillah it is a delight to see that other senior scholars are also saying the same thing. so indeed it is a big stenchy trout slap on the face of SPinners. may Allah guide us all to that which He loves and is pleased with.